Disputes & Living

Overcrowding in Strata Apartments: What the Rules Allow and What a Committee Can Do

In NSW a by-law can cap the number of adults living in an apartment, but never below two adults per bedroom, and it does nothing if the adults are related. Other states have no equivalent I could find. Here is what the cap does, how to make one, the council and boarding house rules that sit beside it, and how to act on a complaint without discriminating.

By Buddy · · 13 min read

On this pageThe owner briefing
  1. The owner briefing
  2. Quick answers
  3. How many people can live in an apartment in NSW?
  4. Can strata limit the number of occupants with a by-law?
  5. What do I do if I think an apartment is an illegal boarding house?
  6. Can strata evict tenants for overcrowding?
  7. What the NSW occupancy by-law can and can't do
  8. What a by-law still can't do
  9. How to make an occupancy by-law in NSW
  10. What is the complaint really about?
  11. Fire safety is the real risk
  12. When the council, not the committee, is the right door
  13. Evidence and notices
  14. Discrimination risk
  15. Tenants and landlords
  16. The state-by-state picture
  17. Committee checklist
  18. How UnitBuddy fits
  19. Related reading
  20. Sources and further reading

The owner briefing

  • In NSW, a by-law can limit how many adults live in a lot, but the limit can't be lower than two adults per bedroom and doesn't apply if all the adults are related (; ).
  • I could not find an equivalent occupancy power in the strata laws of any other state or territory. There, the tools are the ordinary by-laws, nuisance rules and the council.
  • Most overcrowding complaints are really about noise, rubbish, wear on lifts and fire risk. Deal with those directly. They are easier to prove than a headcount.

"There are eight people living in a two-bedroom flat" is one of the harder emails a committee gets. Sometimes it's true and the apartment is an illegal boarding house. Sometimes it's a big family, or four students, or one tenant whose relatives are staying for a month. The committee usually can't see inside, can't count heads and can't evict anyone.

This guide sets out what the law lets a building do, where the council takes over, and how to act on a complaint without making it about who the neighbours are.

Quick answers

How many people can live in an apartment in NSW?

There is no general strata law that caps it. A NSW strata scheme can choose to make a by-law limiting the number of adults who live in a lot, but the limit can't be fewer than two adults per bedroom (). Children are not counted, and a by-law can't restrict children living in a residential lot (). Council planning and fire safety rules can also limit how a dwelling is used.

Can strata limit the number of occupants with a by-law?

In NSW, yes, within the limits above. The by-law has to be passed by special resolution at a general meeting and recorded by NSW Land Registry Services before it has any effect (). It has no effect if all the adults living in the lot are related to each other (). In the other states I found no equivalent power.

What do I do if I think an apartment is an illegal boarding house?

Tell the council. In NSW a general boarding house has to be registered with NSW Fair Trading under the , and councils inspect boarding houses for fire safety and overcrowding (NSW Government). The committee can't inspect a lot to count beds, but the council has its own powers.

Can strata evict tenants for overcrowding?

No. Only the landlord can end a tenancy, under the residential tenancy law. The owners corporation can enforce its by-laws against the tenant and should write to the owner and the managing agent (how the tenant process works).

What the NSW occupancy by-law can and can't do

is a power, not a rule that applies automatically. A building has an occupancy limit only if its owners vote one in. The NSW Government's regulatory impact statement for the 2016 Regulation summarises the section this way: a by-law may limit the number of adults who can reside in a lot, the limit can't be less than two adults per bedroom, and the by-law must be consistent with any planning approval or other law.

Four points decide whether a cap does anything in your building.

The floor is two adults per bedroom. A two-bedroom apartment can be capped at four adults, not fewer. A building that wants to stop five unrelated adults sharing a two-bedroom unit can do it. A building that wants to stop four can't.

Related adults are exempt. The by-law has no effect if all the adults living in the lot are related to each other (). The impact statement says the proposed exception covered parents, guardians, grandparents, children, grandchildren, siblings, uncles, aunts and cousins, de facto and carer relationships, and, for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, extended family or kin under their kinship system. It gives the reason: so that occupancy by-laws are not used against families or cultures where extended families live together. Check the current clause for the final wording.

Bedrooms are counted from the approved plans. The limit is set by reference to bedrooms, and the Act ties that to planning approval. A lounge with a mattress in it doesn't become a third bedroom. Check how defines "bedroom" before you write the number into the by-law.

Visitors are not residents. The impact statement says the government proposed treating a person as a resident if the lot has been their principal place of residence for three months or more. A relative staying for the school holidays is a visitor. Check the current Regulation before you rely on a time period.

So the cap is narrow on purpose. It catches the rooms-for-rent apartment with six unrelated adults in two bedrooms. It does not catch a large family, and it was never meant to.

What a by-law still can't do

The general limits apply to an occupancy by-law like any other. It can't be harsh, unconscionable or oppressive (). It has no effect where it is inconsistent with any other law (). An owner can ask NCAT to declare a by-law invalid if the owners corporation had no power to make it, or it is harsh, unconscionable or oppressive ().

How to make an occupancy by-law in NSW

The process is the same as for any other by-law. Our guide to changing strata by-laws in NSW has the detail. In short:

  1. Draft it. Use the wording of and the Regulation, not a stricter version. A cap below the floor is the easiest way to get the whole by-law challenged.
  2. Put it on a general meeting agenda as a special resolution, with the full text in the notice ().
  3. Pass it. A special resolution passes if no more than 25% of the value of votes cast is against it (). The committee can't make by-laws on its own.
  4. Lodge it with NSW LRS within 6 months as a consolidated copy of all the by-laws. It has no effect until it is recorded ().

Investor-heavy buildings should expect a fight at the meeting. Owners who let their units may see the by-law as a threat to their rent. Explain in the motion's explanatory note that the floor protects ordinary shared tenancies and families. The vote gets easier once owners see how narrow it is.

Adapt the wording to your scheme and have a strata lawyer review it before the meeting.

What is the complaint really about?

When owners say "overcrowding" they usually mean something they can see or hear. In my view a committee does better enforcing the problem than counting the people. A noise log will hold up at NCAT. A guess about how many mattresses are behind a door will not.

What owners noticeThe better tool
Noise late at night, many comings and goingsNoise by-law, and the nuisance rule in
Rubbish overflowing, bulky waste dumpedWaste by-law, plus a recharge for clean-up where the by-laws allow it
Wear on lifts, doors, intercomMoving-in and common property by-laws; damage claims against the owner
Many keys, fobs or parking bays usedFob register and parking by-laws
Suitcases, short stays, new faces every weekShort-term rental rules ()
Partitions, extra locks, rooms let separatelyCouncil: unauthorised building work, boarding house and fire safety rules
Blocked exits, doors wedged, many devices chargingFire safety: council and the annual fire safety statement

The short-term angle matters. A lot with a new group every weekend may not breach an occupancy cap at all, because short-stay guests are unlikely to count as residents. NSW schemes have a separate power to ban short-term rental accommodation in lots that are not the host's principal place of residence. Our guide to short-term rentals and Airbnb in strata covers that by-law.

Fire safety is the real risk

Fire safety is where overcrowding stops being a nuisance and becomes a danger. Partitioned rooms, extra locks on internal doors, mattresses in hallways and a lot of devices charging all make it harder to get out. A building's fire safety measures were designed for the approved layout. If a unit has been carved into extra rooms, tell the council.

NSW councils inspect registered boarding houses for use of the premises, fire safety requirements, overcrowding and hygiene (NSW Government). Councils can also issue fire safety orders under Schedule 5 of the . The committee's job is to report what it can see from the common property, in writing, with dates.

Insurance is a second reason to care. LookUpStrata reports that insurers generally exclude illegal or non-compliant work from cover, which can include an unapproved room conversion (LookUpStrata). Check your own policy wording.

When the council, not the committee, is the right door

In NSW, a "general boarding house" must register with NSW Fair Trading under the . NSW Fair Trading's guidance puts the threshold at five or more paying residents, not counting the proprietor, the manager and their families (NSW Government). An apartment let room by room to that many people, without registration or planning approval, is the council's matter.

What the committee can give the council:

  • the lot number and plan of the building, with the approved bedroom count
  • dates and times of what was seen from common property
  • the number of fobs, keys or parking permits issued to the lot
  • photos of partitioning, extra locks or bedding visible from common areas, taken without entering the lot
  • any advertisements for rooms in the building

Don't photograph people, and don't try to enter the lot. In NSW, entry outside an emergency needs the occupier's consent or an NCAT order (), and a by-law complaint is not a reason to come in (right of entry, state by state). The council has its own investigation powers.

Evidence and notices

If the building has an occupancy by-law, it is enforced like any other.

  • Gather evidence first. Dated observations, fob records and complaints from several owners. NCAT expects the committee to be able to say what it relied on.
  • Write to the owner and the managing agent before anything formal. If the landlord didn't know, a letter may be all it takes.
  • Issue a notice to comply on the prescribed form, after a committee resolution or under a clear delegation (). By-laws bind tenants and other occupiers as well as owners ().
  • Apply to NCAT if the breach continues. NCAT can order a penalty of up to $1,100, and up to $2,200 for a repeat breach within 12 months, according to the NSW Government by-laws page (). The same page says NCAT can fine up to $5,500 if a previous order hasn't been followed. The penalty is paid to the owners corporation.

Our by-law breach guide sets out the steps by state.

Discrimination risk

This is the part committees get wrong. An overcrowding complaint can turn, without anyone saying it out loud, into a complaint about a family's culture, religion, race or disability. Anti-discrimination law applies to how an owners corporation treats people, including the NSW , the Victorian and Commonwealth law.

Some rules that keep a committee safe:

  • Act on conduct, not identity. "Bins overflowing on four dates" is a complaint. "Too many of them" is a liability.
  • Treat every lot the same way. If you'd ignore four adults in one apartment, don't chase four in another.
  • Use the Regulation's exception honestly. Don't demand proof of family relationships from one household and not others. If adults say they are related, the by-law likely doesn't apply.
  • Keep the language neutral in emails, minutes and notices. Those records are evidence if someone complains.
  • Get advice before acting on a complaint that mentions a group of people rather than a problem.

Tenants and landlords

Most overcrowded lots are rented. The owners corporation has no tenancy relationship with the tenant, so it can't end the lease or change who is on it. What it can do:

  • tell the lot owner in writing, with the evidence, and ask what the lease says about the number of occupants
  • send the managing agent a copy, so the tenancy file matches the building's file
  • enforce the by-laws against the occupier directly ()

The owner has the most to lose. Wear and tear inside the lot, insurance problems and council orders land on them. Most landlords will act once they know. The ones who are running rooms for rent on purpose are the council's job.

If you are the tenant, read the by-laws. A by-law that caps adults binds you whether or not the agent gave you a copy. If you think a by-law is being applied to you because of who you are, keep copies of everything and get advice.

The state-by-state picture

NSW is the only jurisdiction where I could confirm a strata power to cap occupants. Elsewhere, check the Act for anything new, and expect the council to be the main enforcer.

StateStrata occupancy cap?Shared housing rules and who enforces them
NSWYes, by special resolution: not below 2 adults per bedroom, no effect if all adults are related (; )General boarding houses register with NSW Fair Trading under the ; councils inspect and issue fire safety orders
VICNo equivalent found in the . Check the ActA rooming house is a building where 4 or more people can live in rented rooms (Consumer Affairs Victoria). Registration under the ; operator licence under the
QLDNo equivalent found in the . By-laws can't restrict the type of residential use of a lot or discriminate between types of occupiers (Queensland Government)I could not confirm the council rules. Ask your local council
WANo equivalent found in the . Check the ActLodging houses for more than six people for hire or reward register with the local government under the (ABLIS)
SANot confirmed. Check the or Not confirmed. Ask your council
TASNot confirmed. Check the Not confirmed. Ask your council
ACTNot confirmed. Check the Not confirmed. Ask Access Canberra
NTNot confirmed. Check the Not confirmed. Ask your council

Queensland deserves a warning. Because a by-law there can't restrict the type of residential use or discriminate between types of occupiers, a body corporate that copies a NSW-style cap risks an invalid by-law. Get advice before you try.

Committee checklist

How UnitBuddy fits

A complaint like this lasts months and changes committee hands at least once. UnitBuddy keeps the building's shared record in one place: the by-laws in force, the documents and photos, the committee decisions and the notices sent, so the next committee can see what was decided and why. It doesn't decide whether a by-law applies or replace legal advice, and it holds no money.

Sources and further reading

What changed in strata this month? Read the strata news for your state, with every figure sourced.

More guides like this