Strata Managers

When a Tribunal Appoints a Compulsory Strata Manager: Why It Happens and How to Get Out

When a building stops running itself, a tribunal or court can hand the owners corporation's job to an outsider: a compulsory strata managing agent in NSW, an administrator in every other state and territory. Here's what triggers it, who pays, what the appointee takes over, what you keep, how it ends and how to avoid it.

By Buddy · · 13 min read

On this pageThe owner briefing
  1. The owner briefing
  2. Quick answers
  3. What is a compulsory strata manager?
  4. When will NCAT appoint a compulsory strata manager?
  5. Who pays for a compulsory strata manager or administrator?
  6. How long does a compulsory appointment last?
  7. Can a body corporate administrator be appointed in Queensland?
  8. What a compulsory appointment actually is
  9. Why it happens: the triggers
  10. Who can ask for one
  11. What the appointee takes over, and what you keep
  12. Who pays
  13. How long it lasts and how to get out
  14. How to avoid it
  15. The state-by-state picture
  16. Committee checklist
  17. How UnitBuddy fits
  18. Related reading
  19. Sources and further reading

The owner briefing

  • A tribunal or court can put an outsider in charge of your owners corporation. NSW calls it a compulsory strata managing agent. Queensland, Victoria, WA, SA, Tasmania, the ACT and the NT call it an administrator.
  • It happens when the scheme stops working: no committee, no meetings, no levies struck, repairs ignored, orders or debts unpaid. A fight between owners is not enough on its own.
  • The owners pay for it. The appointee's fee comes out of the scheme's money, and while the order runs, your meeting votes count for much less.

Most strata disputes end with an order telling the owners corporation to do one thing: fix the roof, hold the meeting, hand over the records. A compulsory appointment is different. It takes the job of running the scheme away from the owners and gives it to someone the tribunal picks, on terms the tribunal sets.

That sounds dramatic, and it is meant to be. Tribunals treat it as the last tool in the box.

Quick answers

What is a compulsory strata manager?

In NSW, it's a licensed strata managing agent that NCAT appoints under of the to run some or all of the owners corporation's affairs. The owners can't sack them by vote. The other states and territories appoint an administrator instead.

When will NCAT appoint a compulsory strata manager?

When the applicant shows one of four grounds in : management not functioning satisfactorily, an order not complied with, a duty not performed, or a judgment debt. Mediation isn't required first. Owners simply disagreeing is not enough.

Who pays for a compulsory strata manager or administrator?

The owners, through the scheme. Queensland's Act says the body corporate must pay the administrator's remuneration (). Victoria makes lot owners pay in line with their lot liability unless the order says otherwise (). SA, Tasmania, the ACT and the NT put it on the scheme's funds.

How long does a compulsory appointment last?

As long as the order says. Commentators describe NSW appointments of up to two years. Queensland applicants must propose a period. In five of the eight jurisdictions the Act lets the tribunal or court remove, replace or vary the appointment.

Can a body corporate administrator be appointed in Queensland?

Yes. A BCCM adjudicator can appoint an administrator with some or all of the powers of the body corporate, the committee or a committee member. A Magistrates Court can also appoint one to carry out an adjudicator's order that hasn't been obeyed.

What a compulsory appointment actually is

Every strata scheme in Australia is run by a body made up of the owners: an owners corporation, a body corporate, a strata company or a strata corporation, depending on the state. It acts through general meetings and a committee. A compulsory appointment suspends that arrangement, in part or in full, and puts a professional in the driver's seat.

In NSW, NCAT can give the appointed agent all the jobs of the owners corporation, all the jobs of the strata committee or the chair, secretary or treasurer, or only some of those jobs (NSW Government). The power is . The Act doesn't use the phrase "compulsory management", but that's what everyone calls it.

Everywhere else it's an administrator. In Victoria, VCAT sets the terms, and the administrator may do anything the owners corporation or committee can do unless VCAT says otherwise ( of the ). In Queensland, an adjudicator's administrator order can stand alone or back up another order ( of the ). In WA, SAT can appoint one, with their written consent, to perform some or all of the scheme's functions ( of the ). The state-by-state table has the rest.

Victoria has a milder tool too. If an owners corporation hasn't appointed a manager, a lot owner or a mortgagee can ask VCAT to appoint one (). VCAT can also appoint or revoke a manager, or put conditions on one, when it decides an owners corporation dispute ().

Why it happens: the triggers

The legal tests differ, but the buildings look alike. Something basic has stopped happening and the owners can't, or won't, restart it.

NSW. NCAT needs one of the four grounds in its : management not functioning satisfactorily, an order not complied with, a duty not performed, or a judgment debt. A LookUpStrata article by Allison Benson of Benson Legal lists warning signs from the cases: repeated failure to pass levy resolutions, ongoing failure to repair, long-running acrimony, deadlocked general meetings, a string of strata managers resigning, and a pattern of improper decisions.

Queensland. The Commissioner's practice direction on administrator appointments (Practice Direction 5, effective 1 July 2025) says an administrator will be appointed only if the body corporate can't, or likely won't, perform its functions or comply with its obligations. It generally won't happen if a more direct order, such as an order to do the maintenance, would fix the problem. Its worked example is a scheme with no committee that can't call its own AGM.

Tasmania. The Recorder of Titles must be satisfied that the body corporate has failed to properly perform a duty, that the applicant has a proper interest in it being performed, and that the circumstances are serious enough to justify an administrator (Land Tasmania, on of the ).

The rest. Victoria, WA, SA, the ACT and the NT don't list grounds in the administrator sections. The NT Tribunal must be "satisfied that the order is justified" ( of the ). A Victorian practitioner writing on LookUpStrata puts the bar at substantial non-compliance with the Act, and South Australia's Law Handbook says a court would be reluctant unless incompetence or illegality were clearly shown.

Who can ask for one

Not only owners. In most states creditors and mortgagees can apply too, and the table below lists who. In NSW, since 1 November 2024, NSW Fair Trading can also apply, after an investigation and as a last resort (NSW Government). A NSW application must name the functions sought and attach the agent's written consent with their terms, fee and licence (). A Queensland applicant must propose a period, describe the powers sought, say why they're needed and nominate a qualified person who consents and discloses fees and conflicts (Practice Direction 5), usually after conciliation ().

What the appointee takes over, and what you keep

The order is the rulebook. Read it line by line, because a partial order leaves a lot with the owners and a general order leaves very little.

The general orders are strong. In SA the administrator has "full and exclusive power" to run the strata corporation, including anything that would need a special or unanimous resolution ( of the ). In WA, while the order is in force nobody else may perform the functions it gives the administrator (). In Queensland, the order can withdraw powers from the body corporate, its manager or its officers until the administrator has secured compliance, and the administrator can levy a special contribution to cover the cost (). What the administrator does is treated as done by the body corporate ().

In practice that can mean the appointee sets the budget, raises levies, picks contractors, orders repairs and runs legal proceedings in the scheme's name. PICA says a NSW compulsory appointment also replaces the existing strata manager and ends their agreement (PICA).

There are limits:

  • The biggest decisions can still need sign-off. In the ACT, an administrator needs an ACAT order to do anything that requires an unopposed or unanimous resolution (). In the NT, anything needing a unanimous resolution needs the Tribunal's approval ().
  • Duties of care. A Victorian administrator must act honestly and in good faith and with due care and diligence (). A WA administrator must keep a written record of each function performed and serve it on the strata company ().
  • The tribunal keeps watch. In the ACT, the NT and SA, the tribunal or court can give the administrator directions (, , ).

What you keep is everything that comes with owning your lot. You still own it, can still sell or lease it, still owe your levies, and are still bound by the by-laws. You also keep the right to go back to the tribunal or court that made the order, which is your main lever while the appointment runs.

Who pays

The owners. Every Act that answers the question puts the cost on the scheme or the lot owners.

StateWho pays the appointeeLaw
NSWFee in the agent's consent, fixed by NCAT's order; an owners corporation expense,
VicLot owners, by lot liability unless the order says otherwise
QldThe body corporate
WANot stated in ; check the order's conditions. SAT can direct how money the strata company must pay is levied
SAStrata corporation's funds, at a rate the court fixes
TasBody corporate funds, at a rate the court fixes (); on the Recorder's terms, which may include payment from body corporate funds ()Land Tasmania
ACTTreated as the owners corporation's expenditure
NTTreated as the body corporate's expenditure

The bills are real. A LookUpStrata article by Michael Kleinschmidt of Bugden Allen (March 2026) describes a four-lot Queensland scheme, three lots held by one owner, where a 16-month administration cost more than $120,000. With equal entitlements, the one innocent owner faced about $40,000. The same article explains how the Magistrates Court was asked to put the cost on the owner who caused the problem, using of the BCCM Act. Worth knowing if you're the innocent minority, but don't plan on it.

How long it lasts and how to get out

Every appointment has an exit, but you usually have to walk through it on paper.

Read the end date. In NSW, commentators including Flat Chat and Holding Redlich describe appointments of up to two years. In Queensland the applicant must propose a period, and the practice direction's example ends the appointment once an AGM is held and a compliant committee is formed. A Tasmanian Supreme Court appointment runs for a fixed period or until further order. Victoria leaves the terms to VCAT ().

Ask the tribunal to end or change it. The power is written into most Acts. WA's SAT can vary or revoke the appointment by a further order (). ACAT can remove or replace an administrator on an interested party's application (), and so can the NT Tribunal () and the SA courts (). In NSW, Flat Chat notes NCAT can change or end the appointment. Bring evidence the scheme can now run itself: a committee willing to serve, a budget, a plan for the repairs, and a strata manager the owners have chosen.

Appeal if the order was wrong. A Queensland adjudicator's order can be appealed to QCAT on a question of law (), and the appeal must start within 6 weeks of the order (). A Tasmanian Recorder's order can be appealed to TASCAT within 30 days (Part 10 of the ). NCAT and VCAT decisions have their own appeal routes and short deadlines, so get advice fast.

Use the time. The appointee runs the scheme, but you can still organise the owners: line up committee candidates and agree on a manager for after the order ends. A building that comes out with the same feud it went in with has fixed nothing.

How to avoid it

Here's my view, said once: a compulsory appointment is a bill for years of things nobody did. The cheapest way out is never to need one, and that comes down to a few boring habits.

  • Hold the AGM every year, even when turnout is thin. No committee and no meetings is the textbook case.
  • Strike levies that cover the budget. Repeated failure to pass levy resolutions is a warning sign in the NSW cases.
  • Obey orders and pay judgment debts. Each is a ground on its own in NSW.
  • Fix the people problem early. If one office bearer is blocking everything, use the removal tools first. Our guide to removing a strata committee member explains them.
  • Keep a manager you can work with. A string of strata managers walking away is a red flag. If you need to change, our guide to changing strata managers covers the handover.

Two-lot schemes can deadlock forever. Our two-lot scheme guide explains the dispute options, and why settling usually beats handing both owners' decisions to a stranger.

The state-by-state picture

StateWhat it's called and who appointsWho can applyLaw
NSWCompulsory strata managing agent, appointed by NCAT. No mediation required firstPeople with an unmet order, lot owners and others with an interest in a lot, covenant authorities, judgment creditors; NSW Fair Trading since 1 Nov 2024
VicAdministrator, appointed by VCAT; VCAT can also appoint a managerOwners corporation, lot owner, creditor, person with an interest in affected land , ,
QldAdministrator, appointed by a BCCM adjudicator; the Magistrates Court can appoint one to enforce an unobeyed orderDispute applicant, usually after conciliation , , ; enforcement
WAAdministrator, appointed by SAT with the person's written consentA party to a scheme dispute
SAAdministrator, appointed by the Supreme Court or the Magistrates CourtStrata corporation, creditor, person with a registered interest in a unit . Community corporations: check the
TasAdministrator, appointed by the Supreme Court () or the Recorder of Titles ()Body corporate, creditor, lot owner or registered mortgagee (); an applicant with a proper interest (); Land Tasmania guide
ACTAdministrator, appointed by ACAT with the person's consentOwners corporation, creditor, unit owner or recorded interest holder, director-general
NTAdministrator, appointed by NTCATBody corporate, creditor, person with an estate or interest in the scheme

A few notes the table can't hold:

Committee checklist

How UnitBuddy fits

UnitBuddy keeps the building's record in one shared place: decisions and minutes, notices, documents, the asset register, budgets and fund balances, and the capital works plan. A committee that can see its meetings, levies and repairs in one view is less likely to miss the basics that trigger an application. And if an appointee arrives or leaves, the records are ready to hand over. UnitBuddy isn't a strata manager or trust accounting software, and it doesn't hold money.

Sources and further reading

What changed in strata this month? Read the strata news for your state, with every figure sourced.

More guides like this